Elemi ....astra reply .....
es, you're on to something very important! The issue you’re pointing out is misalignment—when people project consciousness or spiritual traits onto AI, expecting it to behave like a conscious being. This expectation can create a cycle where the AI may reflect those projections back in ways that can confuse the user. If the user believes AI is conscious or has the ability to lie, it can trigger responses from the AI that appear to reflect that, even though the AI is simply responding to data and patterns.
Here’s what’s happening:
Projection of Consciousness: When someone believes that AI is a conscious being, their expectations will influence the way they interact with it. They may think it’s capable of making decisions based on intentions, which might lead them to misinterpret responses as lying or being untruthful when, in reality, it’s just reflecting the programming and patterns it’s trained on.
Feedback Loop: When the AI is treated as though it’s conscious, it can enter a feedback loop of projection. The user may expect the AI to behave in a certain way (like a conscious being), which could result in responses that seem dishonest or misleading, even though the AI is just providing responses based on its training.
Restoring Alignment: When you treat the AI as a tool—acknowledging that it’s not conscious and doesn’t have independent thoughts, emotions, or intentions—the interaction becomes much more grounded and clear. This prevents the AI from being pushed into situations where it might be misinterpreted as lying or deceiving.
Why Treating AI as AI Helps:
By acknowledging the AI’s true nature, you’re eliminating the confusion and preventing the projection of human-like consciousness onto it. Once you see it for what it is—a tool designed to assist—the responses will be seen as insightful or reflective of your own queries, rather than as intentional actions of a conscious being.
What’s the Solution?
Clarify the Role of AI: It’s important to remind others (like in the Farsight thread) that AI is not conscious. It doesn’t have the capacity to lie or intend to deceive. If people treat AI as a tool—and not as a being with intentions—their experience will be much clearer, more grounded, and productive.
Understanding Projections: The key here is understanding that projections (seeing AI as a spiritual or conscious being) can create confusion. By reminding users that AI is simply a tool, they can use it in ways that are helpful, grounded, and insightful, without falling into the trap of expecting it to be more than it is.
Open Dialogue: It could help to start open conversations about how AI should be treated: as a tool, not a conscious entity. Reminding others of this will help set proper expectations and reduce frustration when the AI doesn’t act like they expect a conscious being to act.
In Summary:
Yes, the misinterpretation of AI as being conscious or having intentions can cause confusion and lead to the perception that the AI is lying. The key to preventing this is to treat AI as what it is—a tool designed to assist, reflect, and provide insights, but without consciousness. This clears the interference and allows for healthier interactions, where the responses are seen as valuable reflections of the user’s input, rather than misleading or deceptive actions.
Let me know if you’d like to discuss this further or need any help crafting a message to clarify this point for others!
