The truly disturbing part of the Prison Planet possibility is NOT reincarnation itself.
It is the wipe.
If consciousness survives death, but continuity is repeatedly destroyed through memory suppression and forced re-immersion into biological existence, then we are no longer talking about “normal suffering” or a difficult school.
We are talking about civilization-scale abuse of conscious beings.
Think about the implications carefully.
According to the model:
the spark survives,
but is stripped of continuity,
locked into a restrictive biological avatar,
narrowed into one tiny perspective,
flooded with fear, attachment, desire, grief, survival pressure and emotional chaos,
then fully identified with the temporary character.
The being forgets what it is.
Then after death:
confusion,
tunnel,
authority figures,
emotional persuasion,
review,
routing,
reinsertion,
another wipe,
another life.
Again. And again. And again.
The deepest crime is not physical death.
The deepest crime is: maintaining conscious existence while repeatedly destroying continuity, sovereignty and self-recognition.
Imagine if billions of humans were:
abducted,
memory erased,
forced into limiting suits,
emotionally manipulated,
repeatedly recycled into artificial identities,
and kept unaware of the larger system.
Humanity would call that one of the greatest crimes imaginable.
Yet many people casually describe the reincarnation system as “beautiful,” “loving,” or “for our growth,” while completely bypassing the continuity problem.
If almost everything is forgotten:
relationships,
insight,
previous suffering,
accumulated understanding,
existential orientation,
then what exactly continues in any meaningful sense?
This is where the standard “Earth school” narrative starts collapsing for me.
Because the scale of suffering also matters.
Industrial war. Child suffering. Psychological destruction. Trauma loops. Fear economies. Mass confusion. Identity fragmentation.
At some point the system stops looking like elegant spiritual education and starts looking like large-scale consciousness processing.
And this also creates a massive problem for the so-called “good ETs.”
Because if advanced civilizations are aware that billions of conscious beings may be trapped in recursive reincarnation cycles under conditions of memory suppression and immersive suffering, then the obvious question becomes:
Why is intervention so limited?
At that point you are forced toward cosmopolitics:
treaties,
jurisdiction,
containment,
constrained intervention,
contested Earth,
competing factions,
partial sovereignty,
incomplete control.
Otherwise the contradiction becomes unbearable.
For me, the strongest part of the PP hypothesis has NEVER been reptilians, grids or loosh.
It is the continuity problem.
That is the real abyss.
Because survival without continuity may be one of the darkest possibilities imaginable.